There is a profound irony happening at the highest echelons of retail right now. We are seeing a trend where loyal, high-spending customers of heritage luxury brands are finding themselves trapped in customer service purgatory. These are clients with proven purchase histories and genuine relationships with the brand, yet when an issue arises, they are met with a digital brick wall. Recently, we’ve seen instances where a client has to utilize advanced Artificial Intelligence tools—like Google’s Gemini or ChatGPT—just to draft a communication potent enough to penetrate a luxury brand’s automated defenses and actually reach a human being.

Think about the absurdity of that. To get "old world" service, you now need "new world" technological warfare. Luxury brands are currently shooting themselves in the foot. In their race for efficiency and manufactured exclusivity, they have lost the plot on relationship management. At Brand Fertilizer, we believe that technology should nourish a brand’s core values, not choke them out. To understand where these brands are going wrong, we first need to remember what "luxury" actually means.
‍

Defining True Luxury: More Than Just a Price Tag

A luxury brand isn't defined solely by a high price point or a famous logo. Those are merely the outcomes of luxury.
At its core, true luxury is defined by artistry, scarcity, and fundamentally, the human touch. It is the knowledge that an artisan's hands stitched that leather. It is the story behind the heritage. Crucially, it is the "white-glove" experience—the feeling of being recognized, valued, and understood by another human being without having to explain yourself.
Luxury is supposed to be an antidote to the cold, transactional nature of mass-market retail. It is a relationship built on trust and exceptionalism.

The "Velvet Rope" vs. The Reality

So, what has happened? Many top-tier brands have leaned heavily into the "Velvet Rope Strategy." They manufacture scarcity to increase desire. They make it difficult to enter the boutique, difficult to buy the popular item, and difficult to get on the waiting list. That financial and access barrier is part of the allure. The problem is that once a customer makes it past the Velvet Rope—once they have invested and become a loyal client—the service model collapses. Brands have disempowered their human staff. In the past, a trusted sales associate could look at a loyal client with a defective item, use common sense, and resolve the issue instantly. Today, centralized inventory systems and rigid automated policies have coded common sense out of the workflow. The human associate standing in front of you often literally cannot help you without a digital override from corporate.
Luxury brands are using automation as a wall to deflect volume and cut costs, treating their best clients as "noise" rather than assets to be protected.
‍

The Paradigm Shift: Using AI to Restore Humanity

We are in a massive paradigm shift toward technological advancement. Luxury brands cannot ignore AI. But right now, they are using it backward. If a customer has to use AI to fight a brand’s AI, the brand has already lost.
The recommendation—and the "fertilizer" that these brands need right now—is to stop using technology to deflect customers and start using it to screen them.
In a luxury context, AI shouldn't be a chatbot designed to trap you in FAQs. It should be an advanced triage system. AI should be analyzing incoming communication to immediately recognize: "This is a VIP client with a significant purchase history expressing frustration. Do not send a canned response. Alert the regional manager immediately."

The Future is High-Tech and High-Touch

‍
If heritage brands continue to force loyal customers to jump through digital hoops instead of empowering staff to say, "I know you, let me fix this," they will erode centuries of brand equity.
True luxury in the modern age isn't about how exclusive you can make your automated phone tree. It’s about using the most advanced technology available to ensure that your best customers get the fastest route back to a human handshake.